Manual vs. Automatic CDL: Which Should You Choose?

If you're thinking about getting your Commercial Driver's License (CDL), one of the first big decisions you'll face is this: manual or automatic? Years ago, manual transmissions were the industry standard. But today, many fleets are also full of automatics—especially for new drivers.

Still, both options have their pros and cons. So which one should you choose?

In today’s article, we'll break it all down for you in simple terms: what's the difference between manual and automatic CDL training, what kind of jobs you can get with each, and how to decide which path is right for you. Whether you're looking for the easiest option or long-term flexibility, we've got you covered.

‍

What’s the Difference Between Manual and Automatic CDL?

At New Sound CDL School, you can either get your Class A CDL for automatic transmissions only, or for manual and automatic by completing the manual Class A CDL.

When it comes to CDL training and testing, the difference matters. If you take your CDL skills test in an automatic truck, your license will have a restriction on it (called the "E restriction"). This means you are only legally allowed to drive automatic transmission commercial vehicles.

If you test in a manual truck, your CDL will allow you to drive both manual and automatic vehicles—no restrictions!

‍

Benefits of an Automatic CDL

Let’s face it—manual trucks can be tricky to learn, especially if you’ve never driven one before. That’s why automatic CDL training is a popular option, especially for beginners:

• Easier to Learn: No gear-shifting means less stress for new drivers.
  
  
• Smoother Test Day: You can focus on the road and your examiner—not the clutch.
  
  
• Still Plenty of Job Options: Many new trucks used by major companies today are automatics.
  
  

At New Sound CDL School, our Automatic Class A CDL program helps students build skills quickly, confidently, and safely—with great results. Many of our students who train in automatic trucks pass their CDL exam on the first try. In fact, our school has the highest first-time pass rate in Washington state!

‍

Benefits of a Manual CDL

Training in a manual truck takes more time and effort, but it comes with some several clear advantages:

• No E Restriction: You can drive any type of commercial vehicle.
  
  
• More Job Flexibility: Many companies (especially smaller or local ones) still prefer to use manual trucks.
  
  
• Better Long-Term Earning Power: You’ll never miss a job opportunity because of a restriction.

If you plan to drive for specialized freight, logging companies, or in areas where older trucks are used, a manual license is a very smart move. At New Sound CDL, our Manual Class A training is the best in the state, with an 80% first-time pass rate!

‍

Does a Manual or Automatic CDL Work Better for Certain Jobs?

The trucking industry is rapidly evolving, with a noticeable shift toward automatic transmissions. According to industry projections, even self-driving heavy-duty trucks are expected to account for 13% of U.S. trucks by 2035. There’s an overall trend towards ease-of-use and automation, but there will always be a need for high-value skills like operating manual machinery.​

Major carriers like Swift, Werner, and Schneider have already transitioned a lot of their fleets to automatic transmissions. These companies prioritize efficiency and driver comfort, which makes automatic trucks a logical choice for their goals.​

However, manual transmissions still have their place, particularly in:​

• Specialized Freight Companies: Hauling heavy equipment or navigating challenging terrains often requires the control that manual transmissions offer.
  
  
• Smaller or Regional Fleets: These companies may have older trucks that are manual.
  
  
• Certain Local Delivery Services: Some urban delivery routes still utilize manual trucks due to specific operational needs.​

Choosing a manual CDL can provide broader job opportunities, especially in specific industries where manual trucks are prevalent.​

‍

What to Expect on an Automatic vs. Manual CDL Test

Your CDL skills test includes three main components:​

1. Pre-Trip Inspection: Demonstrating knowledge of the vehicle's safety features.
   
   
2. Basic Vehicle Control: Maneuvering the vehicle in various situations.
   
   
3. On-Road Driving: Operating the vehicle in real traffic conditions.​

Testing in a manual transmission vehicle requires demonstrating proficiency in gear shifting, including:​

• Smooth acceleration and deceleration.
  
  
• Proper gear selection for different driving conditions.
  
  
• Avoiding gear grinding or stalling.​

In contrast, testing in an automatic transmission vehicle allows you to focus more on road awareness and less on gear management. This can be advantageous for new drivers, reducing the complexity of the test.​ However, it's important to reiterate that passing the test in an automatic vehicle will place an "E" restriction on your CDL, limiting you to driving automatic transmission commercial vehicles only.

‍

What New Sound CDL School Recommends

At New Sound CDL School, we understand that each student's goals and circumstances are unique. Here’s our brief advice on choosing between the two:

‍

Choose Automatic if:

• You're new to driving and want a smoother learning curve.
  
  
• You're not picky about which commercial driving job you land.
  

Choose Manual if:

• You want the flexibility to drive both manual and automatic trucks.
  
  
• You're willing to invest extra energy to boost your job outlook.​

‍

Our programs are carefully designed to equip you with the necessary skills, whether you choose manual or automatic training. Our experienced instructors provide hands-on training, ensuring you're confident and competent on the road, no matter which direction you take!​

‍

Need Help Deciding Which CDL to Get?

Choosing between manual and automatic CDL training is a significant step in your trucking career. Take some time to consider the following:

• Career Goals: Where do you see yourself working?
• Learning Style: Do you prefer a gradual learning curve or are you ready for a challenge?
• Job Market: What types of companies are hiring in your area?​

Our team at New Sound CDL School in Fife, WA is the best partner to help you navigate your new CDL career. Here’s some of what makes our school special:

• Instructor Experience: Our instructors aren’t just teachers—they’re seasoned drivers with decades of real-world trucking experience. They know the road and how to break it down so you understand every step.
• Training Options: We offer both full-time and part-time programs to fit your lifestyle. Whether you want to finish fast or need a flexible schedule, we’ve got you covered.
• Languages Offered: We specialize in supporting non-native English speakers, offering instruction in English, Spanish, Russian, and Ukrainian so you can learn in the language that feels most comfortable to you.
• Pass Rate: With a Washington state-leading 80% first-time CDL exam pass rate, our students leave prepared and confident. We focus on what matters, so you don’t waste time or money repeating tests.
• Equipment and Yard: Our trucks are clean, modern, and well-maintained. You’ll train on a secure, paved lot that’s set up to help you master real-world driving skills safely.
• Class Size: We keep class sizes small so every student gets the personal attention they need. You’ll never feel lost or left behind.
• Transmission Choice: Choose between automatic and manual training based on your comfort and career goals. Want the full flexibility to drive anything? Go manual. Prefer an easier learning curve? Go automatic.
• Job Placement Support: We’ve built strong relationships with top carriers like Swift, McLane, and Sysco. Our job placement assistance helps you go from graduation to employment as quickly as possible.
• Learning Environment: New Sound is known for its welcoming, supportive culture. Our students encourage one another, and our staff goes above and beyond to help you succeed.
• Reputation: Our reviews speak for themselves. Students consistently praise the patience of our instructors, the quality of the training, and the results they achieved after just a few weeks.

Our team will give you personalized guidance, ensuring you choose the path that aligns with your own goals.​ With our comprehensive training programs, modern equipment, and dedicated instructors, you'll be set up for success from day one.​

Contact us today to learn more about our CDL training programs and start your journey toward a rewarding trucking career.